When it comes to comparing a deck boat and a pontoon boat, the most significant difference lies in their technical construction. Deck boats have a single rigid hull, while pontoon boats feature a deck that rides on pontoons acting as the hulls. Despite these differences, both types of boats serve similar purposes in the boating world and cater to specific niches. However, there are various factors to consider when determining which option is best suited for individual preferences and needs. So, which one would be the ideal choice for you and your family? Delving into the comparison between deck boats and pontoon boats will provide the answers you seek.
Differences in Construction Materials
When it comes to deck boats and pontoon boats, the construction materials play a significant role in differentiating the two types of boats. Deck boats are primarily constructed of fiberglass, while pontoon boats are mainly made from aluminum. However, there are exceptions to this rule, as there are aluminum deck boats and even rare occurrences of fiberglass pontoon boats. The construction of the “pontoons” and the bridge between them is typically one molded part, which can make them similar to power catamarans.
Deck Boat vs. Pontoon Boat: Visual Comparison
At first glance, it can be challenging to distinguish between a deck boat and a pontoon boat by looking at overhead pictures or layout drawings. Apart from the construction materials, there are other factors that set these two types of boats apart. Let’s explore the pros and cons of deck boats and pontoons to understand their differences more clearly.
Deck Boat Advantages
- Deck boats have a larger surface area, providing more buoyancy, higher weight and passenger capacities.
- They handle large waves better, thanks to the increased buoyancy in the bow.
- Deck boats generally offer a sportier feel in their handling compared to pontoon boats.
- They feature more integrated accessories, resulting in less noise and improved longevity.
- Choosing a deck boat is often easier due to fewer available layouts.
- Many people prefer the sleek look of the gel coat over bare or painted aluminum.
Deck Boat Disadvantages
- Due to their fiberglass construction, deck boats tend to weigh more than pontoon boats, except for aluminum models.
- They offer limited choices in terms of layouts.
- Regular waxing is required for fiberglass boats, including deck boats.
- Wider molded fiberglass gunwales may result in less room inside compared to pontoons of equal length and beam.
Pontoon Boat Advantages
- Pontoon boats offer a wide range of furniture layouts to choose from, providing semi-customization options.
- Some manufacturers offer both pontoon and “tri-toon” models, allowing users to select the desired level of performance.
- The tall fences surrounding the deck of a pontoon boat are ideal for keeping kids and pets secure.
- They are lighter in weight, making them easier to tow with smaller vehicles.
- Maintenance is minimal and generally limited to cleaning and minor repairs.
- Pontoon boats maximize usable space, offering platforms at both bow and stern for boarding.
Pontoon Boat Disadvantages
- Pontoon boats are not the best choice for rough water conditions.
- The life expectancy of a pontoon boat is generally shorter than that of a molded fiberglass boat.
- Most storage areas in pontoons are not entirely waterproof due to rotomolded seat bases.
- Some pontoons are designed for freshwater use only and may suffer from corrosion if used in saltwater environments.
- Due to their tall fences and shallow, rounded pontoons, they can be easily blown around by the wind.
- The handling of pontoon boats tends to be less sporty compared to monohull boats.
Performance Differences: Deck Boats vs. Pontoon Boats
When it comes to performance, many boaters prioritize sharp turns and quick planing. Deck boats are known for their ability to carve sharp turns and swiftly jump onto plane, offering a performance edge in these aspects. Additionally, many deck boats are capable of reaching highway speeds, making them a popular choice for those who value speed on the water. On the other hand, pontoon boats have evolved significantly from their slow and mushy handling of the past. With the introduction of tri-toon pontoon boats, equipped with a third “log” for added stability and buoyancy, pontoon boats can now rival fiberglass monohulls in terms of speed.
However, speed is not the only consideration for all boaters. Some individuals prefer a leisurely cruise down a lake or river, without the need for high speeds. For these boaters, there are plenty of low-horsepower pontoon boats available. These boats come with lower costs, including reduced fuel consumption and maintenance expenses. In contrast, deck boats are typically designed for faster cruising speeds, with fewer options available for low-horsepower engines.
Comparison of Rough Water Handling: Deck Boats vs. Pontoons
When it comes to rough water handling, deck boats have a clear advantage over pontoons. The design of deck boats, with their monohulls made of fiberglass and upswept bows, allows them to rise above the waves instead of being washed over. Additionally, their complex V-shaped deadrise helps to split open the waves, making them more adept at handling rough waters. In comparison, pontoons are rarely seen outside of lakes, calm rivers, and protected bays, as they are not as well-equipped to handle rough waters. However, it is important to note that tri-toons do have an advantage over pontoons with two logs, and can handle waves better than expected. Pontoons also tend to experience less rocking and rolling in a beam sea compared to deck boats. Nevertheless, in the debate of deck boat vs pontoon rough water handling, deck boats generally come out on top, thanks to their ability to push waves out of the way due to their weight.
Comparing Safety: Deck Boats vs. Pontoon Boats
When it comes to safety, both deck boats and pontoon boats in the United States are required to meet the U.S. Coast Guard safety standards. Additionally, boat manufacturers certified by the National Marine Manufacturer Association (NMMA) adhere to an even higher standard of safety. Most deck boats and pontoons are NMMA certified, ensuring a high level of safety for both types of boats. Ultimately, the safety of these boats depends on the competency and good judgment of the captain.
Comparing Space and Capacity of Deck Boats and Pontoon Boats
When it comes to the interior volume, pontoon boats generally have an edge over deck boats due to their wider gunwales. However, it’s important to note that even though deck boats carry their beam forward, some may narrow towards the bow, which can reduce the interior space. Despite this, deck boats often have a higher passenger capacity and can support more weight compared to pontoon boats. Additionally, the capacity of a boat can also be influenced by factors such as the size and number of logs used in pontoon boats, as well as the choice between two or three logs. These considerations can have a significant impact on a boat’s overall capacity.
Maintenance Comparison: Deck Boats vs. Pontoon Boats
When it comes to boat maintenance, pontoon boats generally require less upkeep compared to deck boats and other fiberglass boats. This is primarily because the hull of a pontoon boat does not need to be waxed. Similarly, the topsides of a pontoon boat, being free of gel coated surfaces, require less rubbing and buffing throughout the season. However, both types of boats will still need regular washing after use, cleaning of cushions and canvass, and routine maintenance of the powerplant.
Price Comparison: Deck Boats vs. Pontoon Boats
When comparing deck boats and pontoon boats in terms of price, it’s important to note that the range is quite wide for both types of boats. Deck boats can be found at relatively low prices, while some come with a hefty price tag. Similarly, pontoon boats also have a wide price range, from easily affordable models to those that cost as much as a house. Therefore, it’s impossible to make a general statement about the price of deck boats versus pontoon boats.
Consider Your Preferences
Ultimately, whether you end up with a deck boat or a pontoon boat will depend on your personal preferences and priorities. Each type of boat has its own advantages and disadvantages, so the decision will be based on what matters most to you. Perhaps, in the end, you may find that both types of boats offer something that appeals to you, leading you to consider both options.